Comfort in the face of tragedy
Advertisements
December 9, 2009
Yesterday morning, I sat at a table where the word “rape” was mentioned as easily as “lunch.” People are able to have the word simply roll off their tongue, with no side effects. Matter-of-factly. Knowing it is a terrible experience, a horrifying act, it is merely something that has happened to others — it is not part of their history, so it does not dwell in their memory.
Dwell...no. Haunt. Rape. The word is a trigger. The act haunts me. I was raped.
Two horrific times in my life: 1978. 1998.
I remember the dates. I remember the times. I remember it all.
I couldn’t sit there, yesterday. It was a Torah class. Yet the word “rape” became part of it’s focus. Unfortunately, evil has been around since the beginning of creation. I didn’t know that rape was a part of my Jewish history as well.
I sat there, in my shul, as the rabbi mentioned the day’s lesson overview. Dina was raped. We were going to talk about clothing, being provocative, consequences, and more. I couldn’t take it. And I couldn’t stop the movie from playing in my head. I saw my ex-husband, the red shirt he had on, the navy dress I was wearing, the couch he had thrown me on. I started to feel the pain on my arms as he held me down...then I thought I was going to throw up in the shul. In my sacred haven. I had to run.
Sometimes, as I am driving, I look at other women in their cars. I see them as I think they are. And I wonder. How does it feel to have never been raped? What would it feel like to have never had hands laid on you for hurt, to do damage, to inflict pain — to have never been beaten until bones broke and bleeding was unmanageable?
What do they feel like, these other women?
Then the red light will change, and it is time to step on the gas pedal, back to my reality of trying to forget.
I don’t feel sorry for myself. What has happened to me in my course of life is all part of a plan. Everything I have experienced, brings me another opportunity or another ounce of sensitivity and compassion. I don’t understand it now, but perhaps, someday I will. I don’t ask “why”...but what can I do with it. What can I do with what happened to me? My own answer comes in telling others. I warn women, young and old, about danger signs. I tell of safety tips. And I don’t judge.
As my fellow classmates learned of Dina’s story, I cried for the entire morning. Sick to my stomach, I lost control of mindfulness. The movie was playing in my head and I couldn’t pull the plug on the projector.
Then I stopped.
My rabbi’s wife phoned me. She did not have to speak words of wisdom, although she usually does! No, yesterday, all she had to do was listen.
Then I received another phonecall from a worried classmate, and another...until I realized. I shared an important piece of myself with these people whom I felt were no longer strangers.
And today, I am thanking God, for having given me such good people in my life. If it needed to be that I lived through such pains to get to where I am today, then so be it. I am so blessed to be surrounded by caring people.
But in all honesty, I will probably sit at another traffic light today and wonder...just what it would feel like to be free of these torments of rape and physical violence....
God sent us forth, released us from the Garden of Eden into history, to confront mortality, pain, danger, and our destiny.
I wonder what it would be like not to feel haunted.





Comments
Whitney
December 11, 2009
Hi Julie,
Wow-this is a powerful piece. Very well written and it made me pause. Maybe we all replay trauma in our heads and wonder what it would be like to not have those burdens. When I was a child, I was in a car accident with a fatality. I remember the confusion, the smells, the careless actions of the family I was with. Every detail about that day brings feelings of revulsion and to this day, I have fear and distrust around that family.
Happy Hannukah Julie,
xo
Whitney
Dara Carlin, M.A.
December 11, 2009
Beautifully and powerfully written Julie, and thank you so much for having the courage to share your story and thoughts with us! I’ve often wondered the same things as you have; seeing lives devoid of tragedy or trauma… It’s like looking through a window watching a party you can’t join in because they’re in there - safe, happy and warm - and you’re out there - apart from them, trying to comprehend how it must feel to have such joy, not to be shackled to the pain of memories. Your experiences have led you to a higher calling and you’re living proof that good can come from evil. God bless you in all that you do and thank you for helping to educate the girls and women you do; I’m sure your words will help to avert and lessen the legions of haunted women we already have.
With love and aloha, Dara
Jim Fields
December 14, 2009
Julie, as usual you never cease to amaze. Good work and by publishing this piece it will help you to further heal yourself. Nice Job always with Love JIM
Judy
December 15, 2009
Mazel Tov on your publication! This is such an important piece, both for you and for others who have suffered as you have. It took great courage to open up about your experiences and I hope people will read and understand that these things DO happen to real people, not just in the movies. Domestic violence is everywhere, right under our noses, right in our beautiful, affluent communities. Your blunt, honest retelling of your story is proof that survival IS possible and the best evidence of your healing.
With love and incredible respect,
JUDY
Guest SAEF
December 17, 2009
Sometimes it takes courage to grow.
Thank you for giving me the opportunity.
Farida Paston
December 23, 2009
Julie - Mazel Tov on this brave accomplishment!
Love,
Don, Farida Melissa & Ashley Paston
Guest SAEF
December 26, 2009
This is a very moving story….Thank you for having the courage to share it. You are a gifted writer. I look forward to reading more of your insights and thoughts about the world we live in. As I was
reading your article, it gave me a little encouragement and strength to deal with the demons I face.
Thank you again…
Brad
January 22, 2010
I just reread it. Great job, Julie. I’m proud of you. Very engaging, well-written. Mozel Tov. Brad
Gussie
February 03, 2010
Julie,
You are an inspiration for us all. Thank you, thank you, thank you. For those who have had the misfortune of experiencing similar trauma and/or tragedy, your story provides the courage for us to go on and that tomorrow will somehow be brighter. TRhank you…a survivor