Israel trip leaves a lasting impression
Paul and Gail Namm, left, plant trees in Arad with mission mates Sara and Paul Nadel.
November 27, 2012
As their 10-day tour of Israel began to wind down, 75 members of the Monmouth and Middlesex Jewish federation communities gathered in the desert city of Arad to see firsthand the impact of their efforts on their partnership community.
On the 50th anniversary of Arad’s founding, the visitors planted rows of eucalyptus and pine trees, leaving their mark on the Negev town just as Israel has left a lasting impression on their lives, many said.
More than half of the mission participants, who ranged in age from 30 to 85, were first-time visitors to Israel. A diverse cross-section was exactly what Jewish Federation of Monmouth County executive director Keith Krivitzky had in mind when he and mission chair Lauren Reich of Manalapan began planning the trip.
Modeled as a sort of Birthright Israel trip for adults, the mission included Ashkenazi, Sephardi, Orthodox, Conservative, Reform, and unaffiliated Jews. Seven mission members represented the Jewish Federation of Greater Middlesex County. The trip, held Oct. 29-Nov. 6, left New Jersey a day before Hurricane Sandy hit the state.
NJJN’s Israel correspondent joined the group for a day trip to Arad on Nov. 4. “Our goal was to give people a window into Israel and an array of experiences that go beyond typical touristy experiences,” Krivitzky said as their buses weaved through desert cliffs. “We wanted to leave them more knowledgeable, yet hungry for more.”
The mission was “one of the best experiences of my life,” said Reich. “It exceeded our expectations in terms of how inspired and connected this diverse group of people became.” Elana Herskowitz, the Monmouth federation’s development director, also helped staff the trip.
Albert Pressler said he couldn’t “find enough superlatives” to describe what was the 82-year-old’s first visit to Israel. A member of the Middlesex federation committee for his community, the Ponds in Monroe, Pressler said that as an engineer, he was greatly impressed with Israel’s achievements with infrastructure and construction and particularly with Arad, “a vibrant desert city.”
He had been wanting to go to Israel for a long time, he said, but was thrilled that the mission offered him a “great opportunity” to see so much of the country — from Safed and the Golan Heights in the North, to Tel Aviv and Jerusalem, to Arad in the Negev, where he was especially glad to have planted a pine tree.
Israel is a “wonderful, vibrant country,” he said, and “deserves to live 1,000 years and more.”
Joining him from Middlesex were Neal and Elaine Machtiger and Marilyn and Sheldon Blumengold of East Brunswick and Gail and Paul Namm of Monroe Township.
Cheryl Markbreiter of Ocean Township, secretary of the Monmouth federation’s executive board, said seeing Israel for the third time was even more stimulating while witnessing it through the eyes of first-timers. “There were many moments where people were moved to tears. It’s amazing how everyone is sharing their emotions,” she said. “Many of them had no idea federation dollars help support important projects in Israel. People are coming up to me and asking how they can get involved back home.”
For 85-year-old Daniel Gallop of Eatontown, Israel was filled with snapshot moments. Highlights included a traditional lunch in a Bedouin tent, and riding shotgun on a camel with Malik.
As the camel bucked forward through the Negev sand, Gallop gripped the saddle, alternating between giggles and gasps. “There have been many times on this trip that I wish my mother could have been with me,” he said. “This is one of them.”
Ian first got hooked on the country during a Taglit-Birthright Israel trip at age 19. A month after completing his degree at Rutgers, he made aliya. He joined the Nahal Brigade combat unit, extending his service from the required six months for olim to three years. “I felt uncomfortable receiving new immigrant benefits without contributing to the country just like regular Israelis do,” he said.
During the mission, the group also visited a Jewish Agency Amigour project in Bat Yam. Amigour provides apartments at nominal costs for thousands of disadvantaged people. They also visited Net@Netanya, a Jewish Agency program that trains disadvantaged youth in computer technology. The itinerary also included a visit to an American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee project called Maavarim, which helps Israelis in the rural Negev and Galilee develop marketable skills as agriculture work has become less viable.
The trip brought back a flood of memories for Elliott Brown of Marlboro. He made aliya in 1982 and spent the first five months in Arad with the World Union of Jewish Students. After three-and-a-half years in Israel, he returned to the States to practice law. “My motivation was to get back to Israel to visit. I never intended for 20 years to have passed,” said Brown, who was joined on the trip by his father, Alvin, from Boca Raton, Fla.
Arad has been transformed since his student days there, thanks in part to the support from the cluster of NJ and Delaware federations that is channeled to the desert city through the Jewish Agency for Israel’s Partnership 2Gether program.
But Brown’s ties there remain. When the mission arrived in Arad, he made a few inquiries about an old friend who ran the local tennis center. Arad’s Jewish Agency staff located the friend by phone, and the former tennis pals reunited in person before the tour bus headed back to Jerusalem.
“The purpose of having a partnership with a sister city is to create tangible relationships so that Israel is more than just a concept to Americans,” said Monmouth federation president Joe Hollander, who was joined on the trip by his parents, Roz and Sandy. “It’s the personal relationships that happen as a result of the mission that will carry on.”
Jill Garbi moved with her family from Oakhurst to central Israel last July. Before making aliya, she was an NJJN contributing writer.
The following guest speakers addressed the Monmouth/Middlesex mission:
Dr. Gil Yaron, journalist and Middle East expert
Natan Sharansky, chair of the Jewish Agency for Israel, noted refusenik, and former member of Knesset
Rabbi Michael Melchior, former member of Knesset, who served in various ministerial positions, including deputy foreign minister, minister for social and Diaspora affairs, deputy minister for social and Diaspora affairs, and deputy minister for education
Gidi Grinstein, president and founder of the Reut Institute, a nonpartisan, nonprofit strategy group that aims to sustain significant impact on Israel and the Jewish world under the banner of 21st-century Zionism