Conservative leader laments growing Israel-Diaspora divide
Arnold Eisen urges ‘revisioned’ Zionism to close a wide gap
+ enlarge image
Jewish Theological Seminary chancellor Dr. Arnold Eisen, with Rabbi Francine Roston, offered a new vision of Zionism at Congregation Beth El in South Orange on April 19. Photo by Johanna Ginsberg
Advertisements
April 21, 2010
Arnold Eisen is calling for a revisioning of Zionism. Why? The Conservative movement leader views the relationship between American Jews and Israeli Jews as “fraying to the point of dissolution.”
“By and large, the American-Jewish public and the Israeli-Jewish public do not much care about the Jewish community on the other side of that divide,” said Eisen. “I think this calls for a reevaluation of Zionism.”
The chancellor of the Jewish Theological Seminary spoke before a crowd at Congregation Beth El in South Orange on April 19, Yom Ha’atzmaut.
“The realities that face us in 2010 are different from the realities we faced in 1967 and 1973 and certainly different from the reality in 1948, and so one of things we have to do is think together again about what Zionism means because none of the existing models are satisfactory,” he said.
That’s no small order for an administrator who, appointed to helm JTS three years ago, is dealing with budgetary constraints that are limiting the speed of the implementation of his vision.
Calling himself a religious Zionist, he offered up a model of Zionism that not only fuses those two facets of his own identity, but also marries them to the philosophy of Conservative Judaism.
Eisen said he views the State of Israel as an opportunity not only to ensure the survival of the Jews, so there can be a Judaism, but also test the promise of Torah as a way of life. He wasn’t referring to dissolving the borders between religion and state, or making Halacha, Jewish law, the law of the land. Instead, he spoke of looking into sacred texts to find teachings that can be adapted to the modern world.
“We Jews in the world have the task of making Israel an instrument for new kinds of Jewish communities and new kinds of Torah,” he said. “What does Torah, in the broad sense, have to say about health care? What does Torah have to say about foreign policy? And what does Torah have to say about being responsible for a minority of people who are citizens of your state but are not Jewish?
“That is, to me, a tremendous opportunity to expand the notion of mitzva.”
Conservative Jews, with a commitment to both tradition and change, have “particular purchase” on this issue.
“We have particular wisdom, insight to bring to bear, particular experience at bringing Judaism up to date and having it respond to new challenges,” he said.
Israel also serves as the one place where public time and space have a distinctly Jewish flavor. “Although we try to create Jewish time and space in synagogues, camps, and schools, the absence of a Jewish time and space bedevils us; Israel gives it to us,” said Eisen.
Eisen would like to see Diaspora Jews better educated about real-life experience in Israel — and “not just the larger-than-life story of Israel.”
“Most Jewish education has a little about Yom Ha’atzmaut, but there is no serious Israel education. That’s sad…,” he said.
He urged ways of identifying with Israel beyond philanthropy and advocacy.
“The answer has to lie in fostering experiences of American Jews involving Israel and fostering experience of Israeli Jews of us. Birthright is the beginning of this,” he said, referring to the free trips to Israel for young people, “but only the beginning, and there’s a lot more that’s needed.”
Finally, in order to remedy the lack of relationship between Diaspora and Israeli Jews, he suggested the creation of conversations, or “shared partnerships,” among Jews on both sides of the divide.
“The most important thing is Jew-to-Jew relationships, doctors talking to doctors, because they have something to converse about, lawyers talking to lawyers, I-T people talking to I-T people.”
Failure to “revision” and “revitalize” Zionism will come at a steep price, said Eisen.
“God forbid we get to a point where the American president and the American Congress know that most Jews don’t care very much about Israel and are free to make terrible decisions,” he said.
Comments
Esther
April 22, 2010
If I can take this opportunity to say what I think the Torah says about health care, I think the Torah tells us to give Tzedakah. Charity is given of our own free will. It does not call for “Social Justice” whereby the government mandates, through taxes,* the transfer of wealth from one segment of society to another. This is in essence stealing. The Torah says, “thou shalt not steal.”
*In order to provide health care to vast segments of our society, taxes will inevitably rise significantly.
Stacy Gittleman
April 22, 2010
One way that many Federations are trying to bridge this gap is through the Partnership 2000 programs, where cities in the US are matched with sister cities in Israel. We have cultural, artistic and educational exchanges as well as summer programs where Israeli and US kids stay with each other.
I have participated in the education bridge in my city. I visited Israel, the classrooms in my host city, and Israelis in Modi’in have visited here, stayed in our homes. We plan, we try to make connections between our classrooms, but in reality, when we return home, reality is waiting for us, and we go back to our regular obligations. It’s hard to make the follow through happen. It’s not for lack of interest, its just we get busy with our lives and have little time to pick our heads up from the grind on both sides of the sea to view the big picture.
Toby D.
April 23, 2010
Right on, Queen Esther! The same emotional pathologies that have reduced Reform synogogues and community organizations into simplistic platforms for leftist rhetoric are trying to infect and dilute Conservative Judaism as well. Read “The Hijacking of Tikkun Olam” for more insight.
SMARTY2004
May 05, 2010
Esther, I am appalled by your interpretation of the Torah! I assume you are well covered by health care and otherwise financially. Best wishews - I hope you stay well and never need tzedakah to pay your healthcare bills!